These are the people to blame if the Caltongate Scheme results in the withdrawl of Edinburgh's World Heritage status. If you wish to comment on their voting perfomance on heritage matters click on the brown envelopes below each Councillor

Vital elements of the controversial £300 million Caltongate scheme received the go-ahead from city councillors.

Alistair Paisley	Cameron Rose	Charles Dundas	Elaine Morris	Eric Milligan	Stuart McIvor

At a stormy meeting of the council's planning committee, elements of the controversial £300 million Caltongate scheme including a new five-star hotel which requirews the demolition of a listed school building, conference centre, plus dozens of homes, shops and offices in the Old Town, were supported by a majority of the 14 politicians.

Gary Peacock	Joanna Mowat	Lesley Hinds	Marjorie Thomas	Norma Hart	Rob Minn

However, contentious proposals to demolish all but the facade of historic Canongate tenements were put on hold, and the developers Mountrgange have been asked to look at ways of retaining the buildings for affordable housing.

The lengthy meeting, which carried on until 7.15pm, was attended by a large number of protesters, who regularly heckled the councillors.

Green councillor Steve Burgess and the SNP's Colin Keir opposed many of the separate plans for the Old Town site, but Lib Dem convener Jim Lowrie spoke out in support of the scheme.